From Joel Spolsky, talking about the Gutenberg editor in WordPress and block editors in general:
This kind of “insert block” user interface concept is showing up in almost every blogging tool, web editor, note-taking app, and content management system. People like it and it makes sense. (Emphasis mine)
(Via Joel On Software)
I disagree with the bolded statement. Don’t take my word for it. Check out Reddit and other on-line communities where people are looking for alternatives.
Writing for me is about the content. Traditional typewriter-on-paper type interfaces like word processors provide are better for the flow of writing. I don’t want to have to think about “is this MP4 of an old song that has a static image of the artist and title an Audio block or a Video block” or “is this stream of consciousness I want to reference a quote or verse” or other meaningless distinctions.
Write. Edit. Repeat as necessary. Put in the supporting elements. Edit. Publish.
Powerpoint and block editors are about where things will go first. How big or small will they be? What kind of element (see above)? Oh, my writing is too big for where I want the text block to be. Let me move things around. Now I need to fix that the font size in block a is different than block c. Ohhh, now I need to make a change across all the blocks because I’m using a new template.
Ugh. Some people like the block editor metaphor, to be fair. I applaud them. It is not for me. Don’t say “people like it and it makes sense,” because some don’t like it and for them it does not make sense … I’m also talking to you, Automattic (makers of WordPress).